What is a clawback window, and when is the first safe day to close?
2 min read · Bank bonuses, Strategy
A clawback window is the period, counted from the day you opened the account, during which closing it lets the bank take back the bonus or charge an early-closure fee. The first safe day to close is the opening date plus that window, provided the bonus has already posted. Where the offer prints no window, the safe day is unknown, and the bank is the only one who can name it.
The bonus has posted, and the account is now a chore. Whether you can close it depends on a clause that is easy to miss, because it is written about the account rather than about the bonus.
What the window is
A clawback window is a period, counted from the day the account was opened, during which closing the account entitles the bank to take the bonus back or to charge an early-closure fee. It exists so that a bonus buys the bank a customer for a while, not for an afternoon.
It is separate from the deposit window. The deposit window is how long you have to meet the requirement, and at Chase and Wells Fargo it is 90 days. 1 2 The clawback window is how long you have to stay, and it can run past the day the bonus is paid.
How to date the first safe day
Two conditions, both required.
- The bonus has posted, and you can see it in the account activity.
- The opening date plus the printed window has passed.
An account opened on 1 March with a 180-day window is safe to close from 28 August, if the bonus has posted by then. If the bonus arrives in September, the safe day moves to the day it posts, because condition 1 comes first.
Where to find the number
Three places, in this order.
- The offer terms, under close, closure or early.
- The account's fee schedule, where an early-closure fee is often printed as a plain account fee with no mention of the bonus.
- The bank, in writing, when neither document prints a number.
The Chase and Wells Fargo terms we read print no fixed window. 1 2 Both require the account to be open when the bonus is paid, and Wells Fargo says it "may close or restrict the account and decline or reverse any bonus" where it suspects promotional abuse. 2 That is a reserved right without a date, which is exactly the case where asking the bank is the only honest move.
Why unknown is not zero
A tracker that fills a missing window with zero tells you it is safe to close on payout day. A tracker that fills it with a typical figure tells you a date the bank never agreed to. Either way the date reads as a fact, and the reader acts on it.
The correct output when the page prints nothing is no date and a plain note that the bank has to be asked. That is what CardLab's tracker does, and the same rule applies to the ROI figure: an unknown window is not counted as committed time, and the page says so.
What to keep
- The offer terms with the date you read them.
- The fee schedule in force on the day you opened.
- The bank's written answer, if you had to ask.
Three documents, and a closure nobody can argue with.
Common questions
How do I work out the first safe day to close?
Take the day the account was opened and add the number of days the offer prints as its early-close or clawback period. If the bonus has posted by then, that is the first safe day. If it has not, wait for the bonus first, because both conditions have to hold.
Is the clawback window the same as the deposit window?
No. The deposit window is how long you have to meet the requirement, usually 90 days at the large banks. The clawback window is how long you must keep the account open, and it is usually longer, commonly 90 to 180 days, and sometimes printed only in the account's fee schedule.
What if the offer does not print one?
Treat the date as unknown and ask the bank in secure messaging before you close. The Chase and Wells Fargo terms we read print none, and both still reserve the right to reverse a bonus for promotional abuse, so silence is not permission.
Does CardLab guess the window when the page is silent?
No. CardLab reads the window from the offer page where it prints one and shows the safe-to-close date from it. Where the page prints none, the tracker says so and shows no date, because a guessed date would be presented as a fact.
Sources
CardLab tracks the cards you hold and the bonuses you are chasing, with every rate read from the issuer's own page.
Get CardLabWhich card to use